Jon Rose: The People's Music

As it is, this is a dose of pretty anonymous writing for strings with the occasional accompaniment of "industrial percussion" — presumably to symbolise the noise of the title in the case of "Working People" — which in its way might just be a celebration of wearying physical labour by people who will never have to do it.

"Some People" has some hectoring narrative, including a quote from Mao Zedong, and this has the effect of making the absence of a visual element even more pronounced. Here, as elsewhere, the music doesn't have enough character to stand on its own, although on "People Control" (oh the irony!), something distinctive does emerge, and it's here that we get closest to Rose's highly individual work both as an improvising violinist and as a sculptor and manipulator of sound; the absence of the visual element and the concept behind the work are both irrelevant, which is as it should be if the music is to be evaluated for what it is.

Ultimately, for all of its surrealism and wildness, neither of which are overtly detectable in the music itself, this disc has all the maddening aspects of the average soundtrack, and unless the listener is able to approach it without any prior information as to what the music is all about, the effect is the opposite of watching, say, Citizen Kane with no volume.

Comments